Disputable aspects of compensating losses and general director’s liability at a legal entity during the ongoing reform of the RF civil legislation

About the authors:

Sergey V. Romanchuk, Cand. Sci. (Jur.), Associate Professor, Department of Civil and Legal Disciplines, Institute of State and Law, University of Tyumen, Tyumen, Russia ser-romanchuk@mail.ru
Reagan Lee V. Bezugliy, Master Student of Jurisprudence, Institute of State and Law, University of Tyumen, Tyumen, Russia rvbezugli@gmail.com

Abstract:

This article looks into a universal way of restoring violated rights in corporate relations: compensating losses within the implementatied the provisions of the Article 53.1 of the RF Civil Code . In the period of its active reform in 2014, the Article 53.1 was introduced, which regulates the corporate liability of individual and collective bodies of a legal entity for decision-making. Analyzing the composition of a corporate offense, as well as the criteria for the onset of civil liability, the authors conclude that the assessment nature of the signs of "bad faith" and "unreasonableness,» which in turn cannot be recognized as established for the unambiguous application of these provisions of the law and the formation of uniform judicial practice. The analysis of court practice demonstrates significant difficulties in proving and bringing to corporate liability the general director, other participants who are members of the governing bodies of a legal entity, as well as beneficiaries acting on behalf of the legal entity. Bringing the general director and (or) members of the board of directors to corporate property liability defines their activities as "high-risk" due to the prevalence of the legislator’s evaluative approaches to defining managerial actions as "unfair" and/or "unreasonable." In order to improve legal regulation in the framework of the implementation of the provisions on corporate liability, the authors propose to supplement the signs of "bad faith" and "unreasonableness" with specific examples of the most common corporate offenses for which the liability provided for in the Article 53.1 of the RF Civil Code arises, as well as to refine the general approach in legal regulation by specifying the signs of "unreasonableness," "bad faith" in the context of the ongoing reform of the RF civil legislation. Due to the change in the functional status of the activity of managing and controlling persons of a legal entity as "high-risk," it is proposed to recommend a legal entity to insure its liability to other participants of commercial turnover from the losses caused as a result of illegal actions of responsible persons, to supplement the disposition of the article with a provision of the corresponding content.

References:

Baybak, V. V. (2016). Compensation of losses at the termination of the contract and the fault of the creditor. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava, 16(4), 119–131. [In Russian]

Bogdanov, D. Reimbursement of losses in Russian and foreign law. Lex Russica, (5), 173–194. [In Russian]

Gutnikov, O. V. (2019a). Corporate responsibility of participants of commercial corporations: problems and prospects of development. Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki, (1), 46–70. [In Russian]

Gutnikov, O. V. (2019b). Grounds for the development of the category of corporate responsibility in civil law. Pravo. Zhurnal Vysshey shkoly ekonomiki, (4), 4–30. [In Russian]

Dolinskaya, V. V. (2015). General characteristics and legal personality of legal entities: novelties of civil legislation. Legal Concept, (2), 46–52. [In Russian]

Zhukova, Yu. D., & Pavlova, K. P. (2018). Foundations of liability of the controlling person: problematic aspects of establishing the corpus delicti in the light of reforming the Russian legislation on bankruptcy. Grazhdanskoe pravo, (1), 10–14. [In Russian]

Zinovyeva, O. P. (2022). On some issues of compensation for losses caused by the establishment, change of zones with special conditions of use of territories. Vestnik Yuridicheskogo fakul’teta Yuzhnogo federal’nogo universiteta, 9(1), 80–86. [In Russian]

Leskova, Yu. G., Zhukova, Yu. D., & Pavlova, K. P. (2018). Civil and legal liability of members of management bodies of business companies: trends in the development of Russian legislation and the experience of foreign countries. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Yuridicheskie nauki, (40), 264–289. [In Russian]

Monastyrskiy, Yu. E. (2020). Indemnification of Losses in the Civil Law of Russia [Doctoral dissertation]. [In Russian]

Novak, D. V. (2017). Good faith in corporate law. Vestnik grazhdanskogo prava, 17(2), 13–23. [In Russian]

On some issues of compensation of losses by persons who are members of the bodies of a legal entity, RF Supreme Arbitration Court Plenum Resolution, No. 62 (2013). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_150888/ [In Russian]

On some issues related to bringing the persons controlling the debtor to liability in bankruptcy, RF Supreme Arbitration Court Plenum Resolution, No. 53 (2017). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_286130/ [In Russian]

On the application by the courts of some provisions of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation on liability for breach of obligations, RF Supreme Arbitration Court Plenum Resolution, No. 7 (2016). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_195783/ [In Russian]

On the application by the courts of some provisions of Section I of Part I of the first part of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation, RF Supreme Arbitration Court Plenum Resolution, No. 25 (2015). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_181602/ [In Russian]

On contesting major transactions and interested-party transactions, RF Supreme Arbitration Court Plenum Resolution, No. 27 (2018). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from http://www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW_301033/ [In Russian]

Pirogova, E. S., & Zhukova, Yu. D. (2019). Actual control of a participant over the activities of a legal entity and nominal exercise of powers of the head: Legal positions in modern judicial practice. Zakonodatel’stvo, (10), 76–84. [In Russian]

RF Federal Law Draft on amending the Article 53.1 of Part One of the RF Civil Code (n.d.). Konsul’tantPlyus: spravochno-pravovaya sistema. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from http://www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc;base=PRJ;n=218852#tdYfpNTgXqX8GYc91 [In Russian]

Aktiv v. Barulin, Ukolov, Shershukov, A40-280739/2021 (Moscow Arbitration Court, 2022). Sudebnye i normativnye akty RF. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://sudact.ru/arbitral/doc/d98z3jexx4Y9/?arbitral-txt=&arbitral-case_doc=%D0%9040-280739... [In Russian]

FIO4, FIO6 v. FIO2, FIO3, FIO8, A40-52052/2022 (Moscow Arbitration Court, 2022). Sudebnye i normativnye akty RF. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://sudact.ru/arbitral/doc/MSntuc5nHtZl/?arbitral-txt=&arbitral-case_doc=%D0%9040-52052%... [In Russian]

Asoka v. Levitskiy, Levitskiy, A40-265263/21-159-1760 (Moscow Arbitration Court, 2022). Kartoteka arbitrazhnykh del. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/e15593e1-d3c8-4d2c-8573-93b09ae61c65/f88f42cb-c31c-4781-83e8-4819... [In Russian]

Meditsinskie sistemy I tekhnologii v. Vasin, A56-41255/2021 (St. Petersburg and Leningrad Region Arbitration Court, 2022). Kartoteka arbitrazhnykh del. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/0d12347d-00da-47b9-a171-200af238b945/7bb1a1df-6132-4cc9-8970-abde... [In Russian]

Agentstvo k "Primirenie" v. Grian, A56-25550/2022 (St. Petersburg and Leningrad Region Arbitration Court, 2022). Sudebnye i normativnye akty RF. Retrieved September 4, 2023, from https://sudact.ru/arbitral/doc/NGgm66U5G0ZO/?arbitral-txt=&arbitral-case_doc=%D0%9056-25550%... [In Russian]

Rotan, V. G. (2020). Civil-law status of some persons liable for commercial bribery. Uchenye zapiski Krymskogo federal’nogo universiteta im. V. I. Vernadskogo. Yuridicheskie nauki, 6(1), 156–163. [In Russian]

Judicial Department at the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. (n.d.). Retrieved Sept. 4, 2023, from http://www.cdep.ru/

Fogelson, Yu. B. (2017). Practice of recovery of contractual losses. Vestnik ekonomicheskogo pravosudiya RF, (11), 57–70. [In Russian]

Tselovalnikova, I. Yu. (2018). Civil and legal responsibility of participants of corporate relations. Aktual’nye problemy rossiyskogo prava, (11), 60–67. [In Russian]