Release:
2023, Vol. 9. № 1 (33)About the author:
Vitali V. Kuriatnikov, Associate Professor of the Department of Constitutional and Administrative Law, South Ural State University (Chelyabinsk); kuryatnikov74@gmail.com; ORCID:0000-0002-1092-3111Abstract:
Constitutional (statutory) council is a new state body of federal subjects of Russia. The council is designed to replace the regional body of constitutional justice, abolished since 2023. At the same time, status of this new body is not detailed in the federal legislation, therefore, it gives rise to conflicting approaches in legal science. It is not clear whether the constitutional (statutory) council should (can) be a constitutional control body. Or it should be a supervisory body. It is not clear what set of powers the constitutional (statutory) council should have. The work uses historical and comparatively legal research methods. The authors study the experience of constitutional councils in republics of Yakutia, Bashkiria and Adygea. The conclusion is made about the main purpose of constitutional (statutory) councils: to ensure the supremacy and direct action of the Basic Law of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation and to exercise its legal protection. This implies the presence of powers: for normative control; on the interpretation of the constitution (charter) of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation; to resolve disputes between the highest authorities of the constituent entity of the Russian Federation. At the same time, an analysis of the laws on constitutional councils of subjects of the Russian Federation shows that they have the authority to exercise normative control in relation to all normative acts of a subject of the Russian Federation and local governments. However, they cannot deprive them of their legal force, since their decisions are advisory in nature. The right to interpret the Basic Law is granted to constitutional councils only in Yakutia and Bashkiria. The results of the interpretation are also advisory in nature, so the interpretation cannot be called an official interpretation (especially since the Constitutional Council of Bashkiria is preparing only a draft of such an interpretation). There is no power to resolve disputes in the laws on the status of constitutional councils in Yakutia, Bashkiria and Adygea. The conclusion is made about the ineffectiveness of the means of legal protection of the Basic Law available in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. Mechanisms are proposed that will ensure the effectiveness of decisions of constitutional (statutory) councils. The right of constitutional councils to give an official normative interpretation of the Basic Law of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation is substantiated.Keywords:
References:
Bredikhin, A. L. & Protsenko, E. D. (2021). Official interpretation of law in the Russian Federation. Vestnik Povolzhskogo instituta upravleniya, 21(5), 13–20. [In Russian]
Brezhnev, O. V. (2015). Resolution of disputes about competence as the authority of the constitutional (charter) courts of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. Konstitutsionnoe i munitsipal’noe pravo, (6), 47–50. [In Russian]
Brezhnev, O. V. (2022). Legal status of the constitutional (statutory) council of the subject of the Russian Federation: the first experience of legislative regulation. Gosudarstvennaya vlast’ i mestnoe samoupravlenie, (11), 32–36. [In Russian]
Varfolomeeva, N. P. (2007). Constitutional and legal nature and mechanism for resolving disputes about the competence of public authorities. [dissertation, Samara]. [In Russian]
Vasilevich, G. A. & Ostapovich, I. Yu. (2020). Features of the rule-making activity of the Constitutional Court of Russia, the Constitutional Court of Belarus and the Constitutional Council of Kazakhstan. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, (450), 191–205. [In Russian]
Ivanova, E. L. (2022). On the issue of the competence of constitutional (statutory) councils under the legislative bodies of state power of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. Akademicheskiy yuridicheskiy zhurnal, 23(1), 50–59. [In Russian]
Kazantsev, A. O. & Savoskin, A. V. (2020). The History of the Creation of the Statutory Court of the Sverdlovsk Region (to the 25th Anniversary of the Charter of the Sverdlovsk Region). Zhurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya, (2), 19–22. [In Russian]
Kobzar, D. A. (2005). Judicial resolution of constitutional and legal disputes about competence in the Russian Federation. [dissertation, Moscow]. [In Russian]
Salikov, M. S. (Ed.). (2023). Constitutional Litigation: A Textbook for Undergraduate Studies. Norma: INFRA-M. [In Russian]
Mityukov, M. A. & Komarov, V. V. (Ed.). 2019. Constitutional Litigation: A Textbook for Undergraduate Studies. Norma: INFRA-M. [In Russian]
The Constitution of the Republic of Adygea of March 10, 1995 (as of June 15, 2022) (1995). Elektronnyy fond pravovykh i normativno-tekhnicheskikh dokumentov. https://docs.cntd.ru/document/804932122 [In Russian]
RF Constitution adopted by Nationwide Vote on December 12, 1993: with amendments approved during the nationwide vote on July 1, 2020 (1993). Ofitsial’nyy internet-portal pravovoy informatsii. http://pravo.gov.ru/proxy/ips/?docbody=&nd=102027595 [In Russian]
Krutogolov, M. A., Krylov, B. S., Ledyakh, I. A., Leonyuk, E. F., & Mamaev, V. A. (1966). Bourgeois constitutions in the period of the general crisis of capitalism. Moscow: Nauka. [In Russian]
Kurguzikov, M. S. (2016). Constitutional control in the Commonwealth of Independent States: A Comparative Legal Study. [dissertation, Yekaterinburg]. [In Russian]
Malyutin, N. S. (2015). Has the interpretive potential of regional constitutional justice in the Russian Federation been exhausted? Zhurnal konstitutsionnogo pravosudiya, (5), 13–19. [In Russian]
Nesmeyanova, S. A. (2004). Theoretical and Legal Research of Constitutional Judicial Control in the Russian Federation. [Doctoral dissertation, Yekaterinburg]. [In Russian]
Nikitina, A. V. (2013). Disputes about competence between public authorities of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation: the concept and mechanisms of resolution. Vestnik Khabarovskoy gosudarstvennoy akademii ekonomiki i prava, (6), 37–52. [In Russian]
Nikitina, A. V. (2016). Problems of resolving disputes about competence in the order of constitutional proceedings. Voprosy sovremennoy yurisprudentsii, (59), 69–75. [In Russian]
On the Constitutional Council of the Republic of Adygea, Law of the Republic of Adygea of April 28, 2022, No. 66 (2022). Ofitsial’nyy internet-portal pravovoy informatsii. http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/0100202205010012 [In Russian]
On the Constitutional Council of the Republic of Bashkortostan, Law of the Republic of Bashkortostan of November 21, 2022, No. 625-z (2022). Gosudarstvennoe Sobranie — Kurultay Respubliki Bashkortostan. Ofitsial’nyy informatsionnyy portal. https://gsrb.ru/upload/iblock/c4b/z_625_20221121.pdf [In Russian]
On the Constitutional Council of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia), Constitutional Law of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) of May 26, 2021, No. 2356-3 No. 623-VI (2021). Elektronnyy fond pravovykh i normativno-tekhnicheskikh dokumentov. http://docs.cntd.ru/document/574747374 [In Russian]
On the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) and constitutional proceedings, Constitutional Law of the Republic of Sakha (Yakutia) of June 15, 2002, No. 16-z No. 363-II (2002). Elektronnyy fond pravovykh i normativno-tekhnicheskikh dokumentov. https://docs.cntd.ru/document/550103176 [In Russian]
On the Regulations of the State Council — Khase of the Republic of Adygea (as of on December 29, 2022), Decree of the State Council — Khase of the Republic of Adygea of December 5, 2012, No. 479-GS (2012). Elektronnyy fond pravovykh i normativno-tekhnicheskikh dokumentov. https://docs.cntd.ru/document/453124105 [In Russian]
On the refusal to accept for consideration the complaint of citizen Petr Ivanovich Zabrodin, ruling of the RF Constitutional Court of April 10, 1997, No. 60-O (199). Unpublished document. Retrieved from “ConsultantPlus.” [In Russian]
Petrov, A. A. (2022). New prospects for judicial constitutional normative control in the light of the constitutional reform of 2020. In Materialy sed’mogo Ural’skogo Foruma konstitutsionalistov (pp. 254–264). [In Russian]
Polovchenko, K. A. (2017). Resolution of disputes about competence as the power of the constitutional court. Probely v rossiyskom zakonodatel’stve, (6), 62–66. [In Russian]
Ustyan, E. A. (2022). Constitutional reform 2020: novelties of legal regulation of constitutional normative control. Innovatsii. Nauka. Obrazovanie, (50), 1304–1309. [In Russian]
On the General Principles of Organization of Public Power in the Subjects of the Russian Federation, RF Federal Law of December 21, 2021 No. 414-FZ (2021). Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, (52), 8973. [In Russian]
On the General Principles of Organization of Local Self-Government in the Russian Federation, Federal Law of October 6, 2003, No. 131-FZ (2003). Sobranie zakonodatelstva RF, (40), 3822. [In Russian]
Khokhlova, E. P. (2022). Constitutional justice in the subjects of the Russian Federation: from constitutional (charter) courts to constitutional (charter) councils. Proceedings of the 20th International Conference for Young Researchers and Students “Evolyutsiya rossiyskogo prava”, Ural’skiy gosudarstvennyy yuridicheskiy universitet, Ekaterinburg (pp. 1078–1085). [In Russian]
Khudoley, K. M. (2011). Powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation: problems of the theory and practice of constitutional justice. Vestnik Permskogo universiteta, (2), 71-84. [In Russian]
