PROBLEMS OF DEVELOPING THE SYSTEM OF CONSTITUTIONAL CONTROL IN THE CONSTITUENT ENTITIES OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION AFTER THE 2020 CONSTITUTIONAL REFORM

About the authors:

Mark N. Rudman, Cand. Sci. (Hist.), Master of Law, Associate Professor, Department of Theory of State and Law, Institute of Law, Bashkir State University (Ufa); markrudman@yandex.ru

Artur R. Turyanov, Leading Legal Counsel, Center for Organization and Conducting Competitive Procedures (Ufa); artur.aspir@mail.ru

Abstract:

This article analyzes the prerequisites for the 2020 constitutional reform, which abolished the institution of constitutional and statutory courts in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. The author identifies the significance and factors for the development of regional constitutional justice, considered as one of the fundamental elements of Russian constitutional federalism. The study provides a detailed analysis of the arguments for liquidating the bodies of constitutional justice of the RF constituent entities with no options for ensuring effective constitutional control at the regional level, which seems to be a reflection of society’s low interest in maintaining the constitutional order. The leading reason for liquidating regional constitutional and statutory courts is the lack of a political request for their activities due to the underdevelopment of Russian federalism. The novelty of this research lies in identifying the relationship between the development of constitutional justice in the RF constituent entities and the political stability of the Russian state’s constitutional system. The author emphasizes the importance of the possibility of establishing constitutional justice bodies in the RF constituent entities for the development of domestic constitutionalism, which is preserved based on the current constitutional legislation. At the same time, the model, proposed within the 2020 constitutional reform and subjugating the regional constitutional justice to the RF subjects’ representative bodies, violates the constitutional principle of the judiciary’s independence. This article propose a hypothesis that the development of the constitutional basis of Russian federalism relies on the stability of the constitutional and statutory legislation of the regions. Consequently, the effectiveness of regional constitutional control is the foundation of the existing constitutional order. Therefore, the institutions exercising such control should be removed from the direct subordination to the representative bodies of the federation’s subjects.

References:

1. Avakyan S. A. 2011. “Anniversary of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation: some results and reflections”. Constitutional and Municipal Law, no. 10, pp. 2-4. [In Russian]
2. Grigorieva N. V. 2020. “Historical stages of the formation of bodies of constitutional control in Russia”. Bulletin of the Tomsk State University. Story, no. 65, pp. 5-12. [In Russian]
3. Evloev I. M. 2020. “Liquidation of constitutional (statutory) courts of subjects of the Russian Federation: pattern or error?”. Actual Problems of Russian Law, no. 10, pp. 141-150. [In Russian]
4. Evstifeev D. M. 2001. “Some problems of the formation of regional constitutional justice”. Russian Legal Journal, no. 4, pp. 139-140. [In Russian]
5. Republic of Buryatia Law of 9 May 2018 No. 2938-V “On the abolition of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Buryatia” (adopted by the People’s Khural of the Republic of Belarus on 24 April 2018). Official Internet Portal of Legal Information. Accessed 17 January 2021. http://www.pravo.gov.ru/ [In Russian]
6. RF Law of 26 June 1992 No. 3132-1 “On the Status of Judges in the Russian Federation” (as amended by the RF Federal Law of 5 April 2005 No. 33-FZ). Official Internet Portal of Legal Information. Accessed 17 January 2021. http://www.pravo.gov.ru/ [In Russian]
7. Republic of Tyva Constitutional Law of 11 January 2019 No. 30-KZRT “On the abolition of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Tyva and the invalidation of certain legislative acts of the Republic of Tyva” (adopted by the Supreme Khural (parliament) of the Republic of Tatarstan on 26 December 2018). Official Internet Portal of Legal Information. Accessed 17 January 2021. http://www.pravo.gov.ru/ [In Russian]
8. Mamonov V. V.2014. “Constitutional culture is the basis of the Russian state”. Bulletin of the Saratov State Law Academy, no. 1, pp. 55-61. [In Russian]
9. Nesmeyanova S. E. 2013. “Actual problems of constitutional justice”. Management Issues, no. 1, pp. 204-207. [In Russian]
10. Pitirimova A. O. 2021. “Constitutional (charter) courts of the subjects of the Russian Federation: an unclaimed element in the system of regional state authorities or its modernization?”. Proceedings of the 19th International Research Conference of Young Scientists and Students “Evolution of Russian Law” (Yekaterinburg, 29-30 April 2021), pp. 1645-1650. Yekaterinburg: Ural State Law University. [In Russian]
11. Republic of Bashkortostan Constitutional Court Resolution on the case on the interpretation of certain provisions of Article 132 and Article 135 of the Republic of Bashkortostan Constitution of 26 November 1998 No. 8-P. Soviet Bashkiria, 3 December 1998. [In Russian]
12. RF Supreme Court Plenum Decree of 25 December 2018 No. 50 “On the practice of court consideration of cases on contesting regulatory legal acts and acts containing clarifications of the legislation and having regulatory properties”. Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, 2019, no. 2. [In Russian]
13. “Problems of constitutional justice of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation: a conversation between Prof. M. A. Mityukov (Moscow) and Assoc. Prof. A. V. Bezrukov”. 2009. Russian Journal of Law, no. 4, pp. 34-46. [In Russian]
14. Savoskin A. V., Kazantsev A. O. 2014. “Is it possible to abolish the constitutional (charter) court of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation?”. Actual Problems of Russian Law, no. 6, pp. 1108-1114. [In Russian]
15. Salikov M. S. 2018. “Federal system of Russia: concept and content”. Legal Bulletin of DSU, no. 1, pp. 53-61. [In Russian]
16. Salomatin A. Yu., Gulyakov A. D., Dunaev A. V. 2016. “Regional constitutional justice - the conquest of judicial federalism or a systemic error?”. Russian Justice, no. 7, pp. 45-48. [In Russian]
17. Stepshina A. V. 2019. “Regional constitutional justice in the Russian Federation: current problems and ways to solve them”. Electronic Supplement to the Russian Legal Journal, no. 4, pp. 92-98. [In Russian]
18. RF Federal Constitutional Law of 31 December 1996 No. 1-FKZ “On the judicial system of the Russian Federation” (amended 8 December 2020 by No. 7-FKZ). Official Internet Portal of Legal Information. Accessed 17 January 2022. http://www.pravo.gov.ru/ [In Russian]
19. RF Federal Constitutional Law of 8 December 2020 No. 7-FKZ “On the amendments to certain federal constitutional laws”. Official Internet Portal of Legal Information. Accessed 17 January 2022. http://www.pravo.gov.ru/ [In Russian]
20. Khudoley K. M. 2021. “Some regrets about the liquidation of the constitutional (statutory) courts of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation”. EX JURE, no. 3, pp. 95-105. [In Russian]
21. Ebzeev B. S. 2005. “Constitutional justice in Russia: consistency and role in ensuring the unity and integrity of the Russian state”. Proceedings of the All-Russian Research Conference “Constitutional justice in the Russian Federation: legal regulation, experience, prospects” (Kazan, 17 June 2005), pp. 15-21. Kazan: Center for Innovative Technologies. [In Russian]