Criminal liability of individuals leading a traditional lifestyle in the Russian North for the crimes under the articles 260 and 222, 222.1 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation

About the author:

Dmitry S. Dyadkin, Dr. Sci. (Jur.), Associate Professor, Attorney, Head of the Department of Criminal Law and Procedure, Director of the State and Law Institute, Surgut State University; Professor, Department of Law Enforcement and Advocacy, Law Institute, Yugra State University; lex.dds@gmail.com, ORCID: 0000-0001-8888-926X

Abstract:

This paper summarizes the key issues of rights protection of indigenous minor peoples of the Russian North (Khanty and Mansi), who lead a traditional lifestyle, exploiting their ancestral lands: hunting, fishing, and using other resources. In the Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area, individuals are often prosecuted for illegal felling (Article 260, Criminal Code of the Russian Federation), as well as for illegal acquisition, transfer, sale, possession, transportation or carrying of explosives or explosive devices (Article 222.1, RF Criminal Code).

However, land management allows for the general public to perform these activities as well, not only for the relatives or friends of the owner of these ancestral lands. Following the casework, the author has found that in a significant number of cases, the investigation fails to establish either the direct ownership of items limited in circulation (gunpowder and ammunition) or specific individuals who performed the felling. Such being the case, the legal owner of the land or its part is held liable.

The purpose of this article is to justify the need for amendments to the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, i. e. providing for exempting those individuals from criminal liability, who have committed acts, set forth formally, sustaining their traditional lifestyle in the North. This new law will allow the protection of indigenous minorities of the North from inconsistent criminal reprisals and to preserve their cultural practices.

References:

1. Adaev V. N. 2007. The Traditional Ecological Culture of the Khanty and Nenets. Tyumen: Vector Beech. 240 pp. [In Russian]

2. Andrichenko L. V. 2010. “On the rights of indigenous peoples of the north of Russia”. Journal of Russian Law, no. 11, pp. 122-125. [In Russian]

3. Bagashev A. N. 2017. Anthropology of Western Siberia. Novosibirsk: Nauka. 408 pp. [In Russian]

4. Bazarov B. V. 2008. “The review of a monographic study D.A. Ivaylovsky on the topic ‘State-legal phenomena as patterns of evolution of statehood institutions (based on the materials of the Republic of Buryatia)’”. State Power and Local Self-Government, no. 4. [In Russian]

5. Valverde C. 2000. Philosophical Anthropology. Translated from Spanish by G. Vdovina. Moscow. 412 pp. [In Russian]

6. Voronov A. G. 1900. “Legal customs of the Ostyaks of Western Siberia and Samoyeds of the Tomsk province”. In: Notes of the Imperial Russian Geographical Society. Vol. 18. Collection of folk legal customs. Vol. 2. Saint Petersburg. [In Russian]

7. The Center for World Indigenous Studies. http://www.cwis.org

8. Garipov R. Sh. 2012. “Indigenous peoples in Russia: guarantees of rights and freedoms”. Journal of Russian Law, no. 6, pp. 67-73. [In Russian]

9. Gurevich P. S. 1997. Philosophical Anthropology: Textbook. Moscow. [In Russian]

10. United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. 2007. http://www.un.org/en/documents/decl_conv/declarations/indigenous_rights.shtml [In Russian]

11. Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Area Department for Indigenous Peoples of the North. https://dkmns.yanao.ru/ [In Russian]

12. Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra Law of 5 May 2003 No. 29-oz “On the Support by Government Authorities of the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra for Organizations Performing Traditional Economic Activities of Indigenous Minorities of the North”. [In Russian]

13. Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra Law of 3 December 2001 No. 85-oz “On the traditional activities of the indigenous peoples of the north in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area”. [In Russian]

14. Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra Law of 28 December 2006 No. 145-oz “On the Territories of Traditional Nature Management of Indigenous Minorities of the North of Regional Importance in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra”. [In Russian]

15. Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra Law of 29 December 2006 No. 148-oz “On the Regulation of Certain Issues in the Field of Water and Forest Relations in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra”. [In Russian]

16. Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area — Yugra Law of 16 December 2011 No. 113-OZ “On Free Legal Aid in Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area — Yugra”. [In Russian]

17. Zakharova T. A. 2018. “Customs of indigenous minorities and federal law”. Journal of Russian Law, no. 4 (256). https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/obychai-korennyh-malochislennyh-narodov-i-federalnoe-zakonodatelst... [In Russian]

18. Zenko M. A. 1997. “On the problem of the study of customary law among the natives of Western Siberia”. VAAE, no. 1. https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/k-probleme-izucheniya-obychnogo-prava-u-aborigenov-zapadnoy-sibiri [In Russian]

19. Zolotukhin S. F. 2002. “Archaic fishing tools and their modern role in the coastal region”. Bulletin of the Pacific Scientific Research Fisheries Center, vol. 130, pp. 857-870. [In Russian]

20. Kovalenko M. N. 2014. “On the issue of fisheries in order to ensure the traditional way of life and the implementation of traditional economic activities of the indigenous peoples of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation”. Paper presented at the Regional Conference of Tribal Communities (24 April). Petropavlovsk-Kamchatsky. [In Russian]

21. Kovler A. I. 2002. Anthropology of Law: Textbook for Universities. Moscow: NORMA — INFRA • M. 480 pp. [In Russian]

22. ILO Convention No. 107 “On the Protection and Integration of Indigenous and Other Tribal and Semi-Tribal Peoples in Independent Countries”.

23. ILO Convention No. 169 “On Indigenous and Tribal Peoples in Independent Countries”. http://www.un.org/en/documents/decl_conv/conventions/iol169.shtml [In Russian]

24. Convention on Biological Diversity. https://www.cbd.int/doc/legal/cbd-ru.pdf [In Russian]

25. Kryazhkov V. A. 2010. Indigenous Peoples of the North in Russian Law. Moscow: Infra-M. 560 pp. [In Russian]

26. Kryazhkov V. A. 2016. “The right of indigenous peoples to traditional nature management (by the example of hunting)”. State and Law, no. 11, pp. 32-42. [In Russian]

27. Kryazhkov V. A. 1999. The Status of Small Peoples of Russia. Legal Acts. Moscow: Yurinformtsentr. [In Russian]

28. Markov V. P., Popov A. A., Nesterova N. A. 2008. “Indigenous peoples (ethnic minorities) in the system of international, national and regional law (as applied to the Komi Republic)”. Proceedings of 5^th World Congregation of Finno-Ugric Peoples “Identity and a Changing World” (Khanty-Mansiysk, Russia), pp. 10-24. Syktyvkar. [In Russian]

29. Interdepartmental Special Report “On the implementation of state guarantees and the protection of the rights of indigenous peoples of the North living in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra” (June 2016). http://map.rightsrf.ru/Karta_Yadro/prav_z_karta/sub_fed/uralsk_fed/hanti-mansiysk_okrug/dokument_han... [In Russian]

30. International Working Group on Indigenous Affairs. http://www.iwgia.org [In Russian]

31. Center for Assistance to the Indigenous Peoples of the North. “The unjust trial of the indigenous peoples of Ust-Avam”. http://www.csipn.ru/glavnaya/actual/3752-nepravednyj-sud-nad-korennymi-narodami-ust-avama#.XGkuUS1eO... [In Russian]

32. Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area — Yugra Nizhnevartovsk District Court. https://vartovray--hmao.sudrf.ru [In Russian]

33. Novikova N. I. 2013. “Customary law in Russian legislation: current opportunities and prospects for the protection of the rights of indigenous minorities”. In: Current Status and Development Paths of Indigenous Minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation, pp. 118-128. Moscow. http://council.gov.ru/media/files/41d4f43e8c526191a1a7.pdf [In Russian]

34. Supreme Court of Canada Combined Decision in the two cases of R. v. Sappier; R. v. Gray 2006 SCC 54 of 7 December 2006. https://commonlaw.uottawa.ca/ottawa-law-review/sites/commonlaw.uottawa.ca.ottawa-law-review/files/15...

35. Novikova N. I., Tishkov V. A. (eds.). 2002. Custom and Law: Studies in Legal Anthropology. Moscow: Strategy; Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology of the Russian Academy of Sciences; Commission on Customary Law and Legal Pluralism of the International Union of Anthropological and Ethnological Sciences; Association of Indigenous Minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East. 400 pp. [In Russian]

36. Karlov V. V. (comp.). 1994. Customary Law of the Peoples of Russia. Moscow. [In Russian]

37. European Court of Human Rights Research Division Report 2011 “Cultural rights in the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights”. Council of Europe, European Court of Human Rights, January. https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Research_report_cultural_rights_RUS.pdf [In Russian]

38. The Complete Collection of Laws of the Russian Empire since 1849. Vol. 38, no. 29, pp. 394-416. [In Russian]

39. UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues. http://www.un.org/esa/socdev/unpfii

40. Legal Center “Rodnik”. http://ecolog.center/ [In Russian]

41. Russian Association of Indigenous Peoples of the North, Siberia and the Far East. http://raipon.info/ [In Russian]

42. Kharyuchi S. N., Filant K. G., Antonov I. Yu. 2009. Social Norms of Indigenous Peoples of the North of Russia. Rites, Customs, Rituals, Traditions, Myths, Moral Norms, Legal Norms. Moscow: UNITY-DANA: zakon i pravo. 279 pp. [In Russian]

43. Special Report of the Commissioner for Human Rights in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra N. V. Strebkova “Guarantees of the rights of indigenous peoples of the north, their implementation and protection in the Khanty-Mansiysk Autonomous Area — Yugra”. https://upch.admhmao.ru/upload/iblock/35e/Doklad_Upolnomochennogo_KMNS_Duma.pdf [In Russian]

44. Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Area — Yugra Surgut District Court Proceedings. https://surgray--hmao.sudrf.ru [In Russian]

45. RF Federal Law of 7 May 2001 No. 49-FZ “On the Territories of Traditional Nature Management of Indigenous Minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation”. [In Russian]

46. RF Federal Law of 20 July 2000 No. 104-FZ “On General Principles of Organization of Communities of Indigenous Minorities of the North, Siberia and the Far East of the Russian Federation”. [In Russian]

47. RF Federal Law of 30 April 1999 No. 82-FZ “On Guarantees of the Rights of Indigenous Minorities of the Russian Federation”. [In Russian]

48. Kharyuchi S. N. 2004. Indigenous Peoples: Problems of Legislation. Tomsk: Publishing house of Tomsk University. 360 pp. [In Russian]

49. Kharyuchi S. N. 2006. “The development of legislation on the protection of the rights of indigenous peoples in the Russian Federation”. Journal of Russian Law, no. 7, pp. 13-22. [In Russian]

50. Small Indigenous Peoples of the North Assistance Centre / Russian Indigenous Peoples of the North Training Centre. http://www.csipn.ru [In Russian]

51. Shishatsky N. G. 2014. “Indigenous minorities of the north as a factor of preservation and sustainable development of the northern territories”. Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences, vol. 7, no. 9, pp. 1449-1456.

52. Anaya S. J. 2004. “International human rights and indigenous peoples: the move toward the multicultural state”. Arizona Journal of International and Comparative Law, vol. 21, p. 13.

53. Clinton R. N. 1990. “The rights of indigenous peoples as collective group rights”. Arizona Law Review, vol. 32, p. 739.

54. Connolly A. J. 2013. “Rights of indigenous peoples”. In: The International Encyclopedia of Ethics.

55. Horuzh S. S. 2008. “Synergetic anthropology as a new approach to the method of humanities. Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 193-202.

56. Ivison D. 2015. “Indigenous peoples’ rights”. In: The Encyclopedia of Political Thought.

57. LaForme H. S. 2005. “Justice systems of indigenous peoples in Canada: does it work for aboriginal people?”. Indigenous Law Journal, vol. 4, Fall. https://jps.library.utoronto.ca/index.php/ilj/article/view/27681

58. Reznikova K. V. 2013. “Preservation and transformation of certain aspects of the traditional way of life of the indigenous and small-numbered peoples of the North, living in the settlements (Posyolki) of Turukhansk and Farkovo”. Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences, no. 6, pp. 925-939.

59. Rudin J. Aboriginal Peoples and the Criminal Justice System. http://www.sfu.ca/~palys/Rudin-AboriginalPeoplesAndTheJusticeSystem-ExecSummary.pdf

60. Shishatsky N. G., Kirko V. I., Keush A. V. 2012. “Socio-economic problems of creating territories of traditional nature management”. Arctic and North, no. 7, pp. 178-184. [In Russian]

61. The Aboriginal Justice Implementation Commission. “Chapter 7. Aboriginal Justice Systems”. In: The Justice System and Aboriginal People. http://www.ajic.mb.ca/volumel/chapter7.html

62. Thornberry P. 1993. International Law and the Rights of Minorities. Oxford University Press.