On the mismatch in the regulation of religious tolerance by the Russian Constitution and national legislation on freedom of conscience

Tyumen State University Herald. Social, Economic, and Law Research


Release:

2019, Vol. 5. №1

Title: 
On the mismatch in the regulation of religious tolerance by the Russian Constitution and national legislation on freedom of conscience


For citation: Kirillov D. A., Sechenova E. G. 2019. “On the mismatch in the regulation of religious tolerance by the Russian Constitution and national legislation on freedom of conscience”. Tyumen State University Herald. Social, Economic, and Law Research, vol. 5, no 1, pp. 74-91. DOI: 10.21684/2411-7897-2019-5-1-74-91

About the authors:

Dmitry A. Kirillov, Cand. Sci. (Jur.), Associate Professor, Department of Civil Law and Procedure, University of Tyumen; eLibrary AuthorID, kdakda@yandex.ru

Ekaterina G. Sechenova, Cand. Sci. (Philol.), Associate Professor, Department of English Philology and Translation, University of Tyumen; e.g.sechenova@utmn.ru

Abstract:

Until recently, there has been no academic research of mismatch in the regulation of religious tolerance by the provisions of the Russian Constitution and the national legislation on freedom of conscience. The problem is that the legislative description of religious landscape, including mutual understanding, tolerance and respect in matters of religious freedom, is contrary to the Constitutional ban on propaganda of religious superiority. It also causes a number of undesirable phenomena in the religious sphere.

Since 2013, this research has been covering a wide range of social and legal issues of the religious landscape. The research methodology is typical for dialectical methodology, supplemented by elements of critical rationalism, modern versions of neo-positivism, existentialism, and other methodological approaches. In the course of the study, the authors conducted conditionally representative surveys, sufficient to formulate valid conclusions on the subject of the article. About nine hundred people from twelve regions of Russia and from five foreign countries took part in the survey. Among them there were more than fifty clergymen; about seven hundred respondents who have identified themselves as representatives of various religions, denominations and sects; and more than two hundred religious agnostics and atheists.

This article aims to amend the legislation on freedom of conscience, explaining its necessity and providing a draft. The relevance of this objective relates to the accumulation of social ideas on the rejection of tolerance, religious isolationism, the contradictions between the world centers of a number of religions and denominations.

The results reveal the mechanism of latent legislative obstruction of religious tolerance, highlight the inferiority of its identification with patience, and state the absence of religious tolerance in Russia. The authors describe three approaches to amending the legislation: “technical”, “conceptual”, and “compromise” — and give grounds for choosing one of the three proposed revisions of the problematic fragment of the legislation on the freedom of conscience.

References:

  1. Baskin Yu. L., Feldman D. I. 1990. History of International Law. Moscow: Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya. [In Russian]
  2. Islam v Evrazii. “Faith patience and tolerance in Islam”. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://islamvevrazii.ru/statya/veroterpimost-i-tolerantnost-v-islame/ [In Russian]
  3. Tolerantnost. 2001. “Declaration of principles of tolerance”. Vek toleratnosti, no 1-2. http://www.tolerance.ru/toler-deklaraciya.php?PrPage=VT [In Russian]
  4. Zolotukhin V. M. 2003. “Patience and tolerance: similarities and differences”. Vestnik of Kuzbass State Technical University, no 2, pp. 94-100. [In Russian]
  5. Karpushkin A. V. 2008. “Constitutional and legal aspects of religious tolerance in relations between the state and religious associations”. Obshchestvennye nauki. Politika i pravo, no 4, pp. 91-95. [In Russian]
  6. The Constitution of the Russian Federation. Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation, 2014, 4 August, no 31, art. 4398. [In Russian]
  7. Islam.ru. “Culture of tolerance in Islam. Islam and freedom of religion”. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://www.islam.ru/content/veroeshenie/43540 [In Russian]
  8. Nesterkin S. P. 2008. “Semiotic aspects of religious tolerance (according to Buddhism of Makhayana)”. Gumanitarniy vektor, no 3, pp. 42-45. [In Russian]
  9. The official website of the Moscow Patriarchate. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://www.patriarchia.ru/ [In Russian]
  10. The official website of the Moscow Patriarchate. “Representatives of the Russian Orthodox Church took part in the meeting of the Council for Cooperation with Religious Associations under the President of the Russian Federation”. 2016, 5 December. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://www.patriarchia.ru/db/text/4466733.html [In Russian]
  11. Tsentr upravleniya finansami. “Religious tolerance”. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://center-yf.ru/data/stat/religioznaya-tolerantnost.php [In Russian]
  12. Sternin I. A. “Tolerance and Patience”. Personalniy sayt Iosifa Abramovicha Sternina. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://sterninia.ru/index.php/izbrannye-publikatsii/item/188-tolerantnost-i-terpimost [In Russian]
  13. Nikolskiy khram poselka Dobrinka. “Patience and tolerance”. Accessed on 11 January 2019. http://pravera.ru/index/terpimost_i_tolerantnost_otlichie_raznykh_ponjatij/0-2672 [In Russian]
  14. RF Federal Law of 26 September 1997 No 125-FZ (as of 5 February 2018) “On the freedom of conscience and religious associations”. Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation, 29 September, no 39, art. 4465. [In Russian]