Money as the Social Reality

About the authors:

Vladimir A. Davydenko, Dr. Sci. (Soc.), Professor, Head of the Research Center, University of Tyumen; v.a.davydenko@utmn.ru; ORCID: 0000-0001-8389-4254

Darya V. Lazutina, Cand. Sci. (Econ.), Associate Professor, Director of Institute of Finance and Economics, University of Tyumen; 72ldv@mail.ru

Elena S. Korchemkina, Cand. Sci. (Econ.), Associate Professor, Head of the Department of Finance, Money Circulation and Credit, Tyumen State University; dozlen@mail.ru

Abstract:

The article attempts to present the notion of “money” from the point of view of the notions “social reality”, “life world”, and “everyday world” in the framework of the interconnected (paired) conceptual-categorical schemes “money power” by T. Veblen, “the understanding sociology” by M. Weber, “the intersubjectivity of the life-world” by A. Schutz, and “the discretionary time horizons” by E. Jacques. The scientific novelty of the article consists in the fact that the social reality through “the prism of money” is considered in line with the phenomenological methodology of “the life-worlds” of an individual and reference groups as a combination of “possible or actual horizons of human experience” (E. Husserl). The money being rooted in human consciousness and in its individual world in this case acts as the different instruments of equivalent exchange liquid resources necessary for its sustenance in the market economy, and therefore money has a unique value for the life-world. The empirical verifications of perceiving money as “the everyday world” in the social reality are given from the point of view of the analysis of incomes, expenditures, and households consumption in different status (quintile and decile) groups on the basis of quarterly surveys of 48 600 households (2002-2016) carried out by Rosstat and based on representative panel studies by RLMS-HSE (1994-2014) according to the grounds of socioeconomic status (education, income, profession), and other Rosstat data. The article presents the analysis of perceving money as a social reality by different Russian social groups in the periods of survival social policy (1991-1999.), increase in the resource base and rapid economic growth (2000-2013), the start of the long economic crisis 2014 up to the present 2016, and a forecast for the 2018.

References:

1. Auzan A. 2016. Nachinaet pakhnut zastoem [It Starts to Smell with Stagnation]. Vedomosti, June 9.
2. Berzon N. I. 2008. “Zavisimost riska i dokhodnosti aktivov ot vremennogo gorizonta investirovaniya” [The Dependence of the Risk and the Return on Assets on the Time Horizon of Investment]. Universitetskoe upravlenie: praktika i analiz, no 3, pp. 65-72.
3. Dobbin F. 2013. Formirovanie promyshlennoy politiki: Soedinennye Shtaty, Velikobritaniya i Frantsiya v period stanovleniya zheleznodorozhnoy otrasli [Formation of Industrial Policy: The United States, Britain and France in the Period of the Railway Sector]. Translated from English by Ye. B. Golovlyanitsina; edited by V. V. Radaev. Moscow: Higher School of Economics, Series: Sotsialnaya teoriya.
4. Ekonomika i zhizn. 1992, no 10.
5. Fligstin N. 2013. Arkhitektura rynkov: ekonomicheskaya sotsiologiya kapitalisticheskikh obshchestv XXI veka [Market Architecture: Economic Sociology Capitalist Societies of the XXI Century]. Translated from Englsih by A. A. Kurakin; edited by V. V. Radaev. Moscow: Higher School of Economics, Series: Sotsialnaya teoriya.
6. Gusserl E. 2004. Krizis evropeyskikh nauk i transtsendental’naya fenomenologiya [The Crisis of European Sciences and Transcendental Phenomenology]. Moscow: Vladimir Dal.
7. Hedund S. 2015. Nevidimye ruki, opyt Rossii i obshchestvennaya nauka. Sposoby obyasneniya sistemnogo provala [Invisible Hands, Russian Experience, and Social Science: Approaches to Understanding Systemic Failure]. Translated from English by N. V. Avtonomova; edited V. S. Avtonomova. Moscow: Higher School of Economics, Series: Ekonomicheskaya teoriya. 
8. Ingham G. 2004. The Nature of Money. Cambridge: Polity Press.
9. Jaques E. 1982. The Forms of Time. London: Heinemann.
10. Khabermas Yu. 1993. “Otnosheniya mezhdu sistemoy i zhiznennym mirom v usloviyakh pozdnego kapitalizma” [The Relationship between System and Life-World in the Conditions of Late Capitalism]. THESIS, spring, vol. 1, no 2, pp. 123-136.
11. Khabermas Yu. 2003. Filosofskiy diskurs o modern [The Philosophical Discourse of Modernity]. Translated from German. Moscow: Ves Mir.
12. Khabermas Yu. 2008. “Otnosheniya k miru i ratsional’nye aspekty deystviya v chetyrekh sotsiologicheskikh ponyatiyakh deystviya” [The Relationship to the World and Rational Aspects of Action in Four Sociological Concepts of Action]. Sociological Review, vol. 7, no 1, pp. 3-24.
13. Kuzminov Ya. I., Ovcharova L. N., Yakobson L. I. 2016. “Chelovecheskiy kapital kak faktor sotsial’no-ekonomicheskogo razvitiya” [Human Capital as a Factor of Economic and Social Development]. Annual report about the social policy. Abridged version of the paper presented at the XVII April International Academic Conference on Economic and Social Development (Moscow, April 19-22). Moscow: Higher School of Economy.
14. Marsh P. 2015. Novaya promyshlennaya revolyutsiya. Potrebiteli, globalizatsiya i konets massovogo proizvodstva [The New Industrial Revolution. Consumers, Globalization, and the End of Mass Production]. Translated from English by A. Sholomitskaya. Moscow: Gaydar Institute, Series: “Strategii ekonomicheskogo razvitiya” under the Ministry of the Economic development of the Russian Federation.
15. Marx K. 1974. “Ekonomichesko-filosofskie rukopisi 1844 goda” [The Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844]. In: Marx K., Engels F. 1974 (1958). Polnoye sobraniye sochineniy, vol. 42, pp. 41-174. Moscow: Gos. izd. polit. lit.
16. National Research University Higher School of Economics. “Rossiyskiy monitoring ekonomicheskogo polozheniya i zdorovya naseleniya NIU VShE” [Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey — HSE]. http://www.hse.ru/rlms
17. Novaya gazeta. 2016. “Virtuoznaya spekulyatsiya. Prodolzhenie ‘Panamskogo dosye’. Kak ofshory zarabotali sotni millionov rubley na torgovle aktsiyami banka ‘Rossiya’, a gosudarstvo — poteryalo milliardy” [Virtuoso Speculation. Continuation of the “Panama Dossier”. How Offshore Companies Earned Hundreds of Millions of Rubles for Trading in the Shares of the “Russia” Bank, While the State Lost Billions]. Novaya gazeta, May 28.
18. Ovcharova L., Pishnyak A., Popova D., Shepeleva E. 2013. “Ot standarta vyzhivaniya k otvetstvennomu vyboru“ [From the Survival Standard to Responsible Choice]. Pro et Contra, no 6, pp. 6-35.
19. Parsons T. 1997. Sistema sovremennykh obshchestv [The System of Modern Societies]. Translated from English by L. A. Sedov and A. D. Kovalev; edited by M. S. Kovaleva. Moscow: Aspekt Press.
20. Polanyi K. 2006. “Semantika ispolzovaniya deneg” [The Semantics of Using Money]. In: Nureev P. M. (ed.). 2006. “Velikaya transformatsiya” Karla Polan’i: proshloe, nastoyashchee, budushchee, pp. 156-172. Moscow: Higher School of Economics.
21. RBK. 2015. “Sovetnik Putina predlozhil zapustit pechatnyy stanok” [Putin’s Adviser Suggested to Start the Printing Press]. RBK, October 21.
22. RF Federal State Statistics Service. 2015. Dokhody, raskhody i potreblenie domashnikh khozyaystv v IV kvartale 2014 goda (2015) (po itogam vyborochnogo obsledovaniya byudzhetov domashnikh khozyaystv) [Income, Expenditure and Consumption of Households in the IV Quarter Of 2014 (2015) (Based on a Sample Survey of Household Budgets)]. Moscow: RF Federal State Statistics Service.
23. RF Federal State Statistics Service. 2016. Dokhody, raskhody i potreblenie domashnikh khozyaystv v IV kvartale 2015 goda (2016) (po itogam vyborochnogo obsledovaniya byudzhetov domashnikh khozyaystv) [Income, Expenditure and Consumption of Households in the IV Quarter Of 2015 (2016) (Based on a Sample Survey of Household Budgets)]. Moscow: RF Federal State Statistics Service.
24. Shutz A. 2003. Smyslovaya struktura povsednevnogo mira: ocherki po fenomenologicheskoy sotsiologii [The Semantic Structure of the Everyday World: Essays on Phenomenological Sociology]. Translated from English by A. Ya. Alkhasov, N. Ya. Mazlumyanovya; edited by G. S. Batygin. Moscow: Institut Fonda Obshchestvennoe mnenie.
25. Simiand F. 1934. “La Monnaie, realite sociale”. Annales Sociologiques. Ser. D, pp. 1-86.
26. Telekanal Dozhd. “‘Deneg net, no vy derzhites’ (23 maya 2016) Dmitriy Medvedev otvechaet na vopros o pensiyakh” [“There is No Money, but You Hold On” May 23, 2016. Dmitry Medvedev Responds to the Question about Pensions]. https://tvrain.ru/articles/deneg_net_no_vy_derzhites-409924
27. Tett J. 2016. “‘Panamskoe dosye’ mozhet yavit’ nam istinnuyu kartinu mirovykh finansov” [“Panama Dossier” Can Show Us a True Picture of the World of Finance] Financial Times, May 10.
28. Veblen T. 1984. Teoriya prazdnogo klassa: ekonomicheskoe issledovanie institutsiy [The Theory of the Leisure Class: An Economic Study of Institutions]. Translated from English; introduction by S. G. Sorokina; edited by V. V. Motylev. Moscow: Progress.
29. Voslenskiy M. S. 1991. Nomenklatura. Gospodstvuyushchiy klass Sovetskogo Soyuza [Nomenclature. The Ruling Class of the Soviet Union]. Moscow: Sovetskaya Rossiya, Oktyabr.
30. Weber M. 1923. Istoriya khozyaystva. Ocherk vseobshchey sotsialnoy i ekonomicheskoy istorii [The History of Farming. The Outline of General Social and Economic History]. Petrograd: Nauka i shkola.
31. Weber M. 1990. “Protestantskaya etika i dukh kapitalizma” [The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism]. In: Weber M. 1990. Izbrannye proizvedeniya, pp. 61-272. Moscow: Progress.
32. Weber M. 2004. “Sotsiologicheskie kategorii ekonomicheskogo deystviya. Khozyaystvo i obshchestvo (gl. II)” [The Sociological Category of Economic Activities. Economy and Society (Chapter II)]. In: Radaev V. V. (comp.-ed.). 2004. Zapadnaya ekonomicheskaya sotsiologiya: khrestomatiya sovremennoy klassiki. Translated by M. S. Dobryakovaya et al, рp. 59-81. Moscow: ROSSPEN 
33. Zarubina N. N. 2005. Dengi kak sotsiokulturnyy fenomen: predely funktsionalnosti [Money as a Social and Cultural Phenomenon: The Limits of Functionality]. Sociological Studies, no 7, pp. 13-21.
34. Zimmel G. 1999. “Filosofiya deneg” [Money Philosophy]. In: Filippova A. F. 1999. Teoriya obshchestva. Sbornik. Transleated from German, pp. 125-153. Moscow: KANON-press.