Sole Executive Body of Legal Entities: Questions of Theory and Practice

About the author:

Abstract:

The questions of creation and the legal entity activities through which the individual participates in public circulation, are of great interest for scientific research and practical activities. The article concludes (based on the analysis of the provisions of the current legislation and existing theories) that the legal entity institution is a part of a legal entity and each legal entity creates a sole executive body. The peculiarities of legal regulation for the activities of the legal entitys sole executive body (the head of the organization) are determined: their activity is regulated both by labor and civil law; the head of the organization, who is its only member (the founder) or a member of the organization, the owner of its property, is not subject to the provisions of the Chapter 43 of the Labor Code; the owner of property of the organization is the employer of the head of the organization appointed by the owner of such legally by law; an urgent employment contract may be composed for any period determined by the constituent documents of the organization or by the agreement of the parties.

References:

1. Akopov D. 2002. “Pravovoe regulirovanie truda rukovoditeley organizatsiy po novomu Trudovomu kodeksu RF” [The Legal Regulation of the Labor Leaders of Organizations in the New Labor Code of the Russian Federation]. Business and Law, no 9.
2. Andreev V. K. O kharaktere korporativnogo dogovora [The Nature of the Corporate Agreement]. KonsultantPlyus.
3. Bogdanov Ye. V. 2001. “Pravovoe polozhenie organa yuridicheskogo litsa” [The Legal Status of a Legal Entity]. Journal of Russian Law, no 3.
4. Braginskiy M. I. 1995. Kommentariy k chasti pervoy Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii dlya predprinimateley [Commentary on the First Part of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation for Entrepreneurs]. Moscow.
5. Byulleten normativnykh aktov federalnykh organov ispolnitelnoy vlasti. 2005. “A Sample Employment Contract with the Head of the Federal State Unitary Enterprise, Approved by the Order of the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation from March 2, 2005, no 49 (point 7, sub-point 7.2)”. Byulleten normativnykh aktov federalnykh organov ispolnitelnoy vlasti, no 23.
6. Cherepakhin B. B. 2001. Trudy po grazhdanskomu pravu [The Works on Civil Law]. Moscow.
7. Dolinskaya V. V. 1997. Aktsionernoe pravo: Uchebnik [Company Law: A Textbook]. Moscow.
8. Dolinskaya V. V. 2004. Grazhdansko-pravovye problemy statusa rukovoditelya organizatsii [Civil-Law Problems of Organization Leader Status]. Zakon, no 1.
9. Federal Arbitration Court of the West Siberian District Decree from August 18, 2010, on the case no A45-4331/2010. Retrieved via KonsultantPlyus; 9th Arbitrary District Appellation Court’s Resolution from May 26, 2010, no 09AP-10226/2010-AK on the case no A40-13990/10-154-41. Retrieved via KonsultantPlyus; 13th Arbitrary District Appellation Court’s Resolution from March 4, 2013, on the case no A21-8666/2012. Retrieved via KonsultantPlyus.
10. Federal Labor and Employment Service. 2007. “Letter from December 28, 2006, no 2262-6-1”. Zhurnal rukovoditelya i glavnogo bukhgaltera, no 5 (part 2). Retrieved via KonsultantPlyus; Federal Tax Service of Russia. Letter from September 16, 2009, no ShS-17-3/168@ “O napravlenii pisma Minfina Rossii ot 07.09.2009” [On the Direction of the Letters Russian Ministry of Finance from September 7, 2009] 03-04-07-02/13. Retrieved via KonsultantPlyus; The Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation. 2010. Order from June 8, 2010, no 428n “Ob utverzhdenii razyasneniya ob obyazatelnom strakhovom obespechenii po obyazatelnomu sotsialnomu strakhovaniyu na sluchay vremennoy netrudosposobnosti i v svyazi s materinstvom rukovoditeley organizatsiy, yavlyayushchikhsya ikh edinstvennymi uchreditelyami (uchastnikami), chlenami organizatsii i sobstvennikami ee imushchestva” [On the Approval of the Explanations on the Mandatory Insurance Coverage for Compulsory Social Insurance Against Temporary Disability and Maternity Heads of the Organizations, Which Are Their Sole Founders (Participants), the Members of the Organization, and Its Owners Property]. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, July 16.
11. Federal Law from June 29, 2015, no 210-FZ “O vnesenii izmeneniy v otdelnye zakonodatelnye akty Rossiyskoy Federatsii i priznanii utrativshimi silu otdelnykh zakonodatelnykh aktov Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [On the Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation and the Annulment of Certain Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation]. Sobraniye zakonodatelstva RF, no 27, art. 4001, paragraph 2, art. 2.
12. Federal Law from May 5, 2014, no 99-FZ “O vnesenii izmeneniy v glavu 4 chasti pervoy Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii i o priznanii utrativshimi silu otdelnykh polozheniy zakonodatelnykh aktov Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [On the Amendments to Chapter 4 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation and Invalidating Certain Provisions of Legislative Acts of the Russian Federation]. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, May 7, part 7, art. 1.
13. Guyev A. N. 2000. Postateynyy kommentariy k chasti pervoy Grazhdanskogo kodeksa Rossiyskoy Federatsii [Commentaries to the First Part of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation]. Moscow.
14. Korshinova T. Yu. 2014. Osobennosti pravovogo regulirovaniya truda otdelnykh kategoriy rabotnikov: Uchebnoe posobie [Features of certain categories of employees of the legal regulation of labor: Textbook]. Moscow.
15. Kuznetsova P. 2011. “Nuzhno li zaklyuchat trudovoy dogovor s rukovoditelem organizatsii” [Should One Enter into an Employment Contract with the Head of an Organization]. Trudovoe pravo, no 4.
16. Kuznetsova V. V. 2015. “Osobennosti prekrashcheniya trudovogo dogovora s rukovoditelem organizatsii” [The Features of Terminating the Employment Contract with the Head of the Organization]. Cand. Sci. (Jur.) diss. Moscow.
17. Lebedinets O. N. 2000. “Zhiznennyy tsikl yuridicheskikh lits (grazhdansko-pravovoy aspekt)” [The Life Cycle of Legal Entities (Civil-Legal aspect)]. Cand. Sci. (Jur.) diss. Moscow.
18. Lyutov N. L. 2003. “Pravovoy status rukovoditelya organizatsii i chlenov kollegialnogo ispolnitelnogo organa organizatsii s tochki zreniya trudovogo prava” [The Legal Status of the Head of the Organization and Members of the Collegial Executive Body of the Organization in Terms of the Labor Law]. Trudovoe pravo, no 2.
19. Meyer D. I. 1997. Russkoe grazhdanskoe pravo [Russian Civil Law], part 1. Moscow.
20. Orlovskiy Yu. 2015. “Osobennosti pravovogo statusa rukovoditelya organizatsii” [The Peculiarities of the Legal Status of the Head of the Organization]. Buisiness and Law, 7.
21. Ryzhenkov A. Ya., Melikhov V. M., Sharonov S. A. 2007. Trudovoe pravo. Kurs lektsiy [Labor and Employment Law. A Lecture Course]. Elista.
22. Serova O. A. 2009. Klassifikatsiya yuridicheskikh lits: monografiya [The Classification of Legal Entities]. Moscow.
23. Sukhanov E. A. (ed.). 2002. Grazhdanskoe pravo [Civil Law]: in 2 volumes, vol. 1. Moscow.
24. The Government of the Russian Federatin. 2000. Decree from March 16, 2000, no 234 “O poryadke zaklyucheniya kontraktov i attestatsii rukovoditeley federalnykh gosudarstvennykh unitarnykh predpriyatiy” [On the Procedure for the Conclusion of Contracts and Certification of Heads of Federal State Unitary Enterprises]. Sobraniye zakonodatelstva RF, no 13, art. 1373, point 3.
25. The Plenary Session of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. 2015. Resolution no 21 “O nekotorykh voprosakh, voznikayushchikh u sudov pri primenenii zakonodatelstva, reguliruyushchego trud rukovoditelya organizatsii” [On Some Issues Arising in Courts in the Application of Legislation Regulating the Work of the Head of the Organization]. Rossiyskaya Gazeta, June 10.
26. Vestnik VAS RF. 2009. “Kontseptsii razvitiya grazhdanskogo zakonodatelstva Rossiyskoy Federatsii” [The Concept of Civil Legislation Development in the Russian Federation]. Vestnik VAS RF, no 11.