Issues of civil procedure development

Tyumen State University Herald. Social, Economic, and Law Research


Release:

Vesntik TSU. law (#3). 2014

Title: 
Issues of civil procedure development


About the author:

Nadezda V. Sukhova,
Cand. Jur. Sci., Associate Professor, Civil Law and Procedure Department, Institute of Law, Economics and Management, Tyumen State University

Abstract:

The author analyzes a number of modern challenges existing in the Russian civil (arbitration) procedure and Procedural Law, mostly bearing international character. It is connected with the fact that the development of law at present is characterized by the approximation of the civil procedural legislation, being the subject of reception in many states. At the same time, whereas legislation is being approximated, the practical application is out of this trend. The irony of the situation is that currently various procedural systems are differentiated not in the sphere of legislation or doctrine, but mostly in the sphere of practice and legal culture, and, moreover, of what one knows as the spirit of law. In the current situation the special significance in the procedural law is given to the exchange of the effective legal experience. This means that referring to certain legislation, legal sources and practice, one should analyze the activity of legislation bodies, prominent scholars, lawyers and judges. The gaps and changes in the legislation, touched upon in the present article, can not be properly comprehended without the efforts of the whole legal community, moreover, the essence of the reforms needed in the Russian civil procedure system can not be defined in an appropriate way.

References:

1. Biulleten' Evropeiskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka. Rossiiskoe izdanie — Bulletin of the European Court of Human Rights. Russian edition. 2007. № 1. Pp. 79-102. (in Russian).

2. Komarov, V. Ukrainian national report. Reforms of the civil Procedural Law of Ukraine and the problem of globalization of the civil procedure [Ukrainskii natsional'nyi doklad. Reformy grazhdanskogo protsessual'nogo zakonodatel'stva Ukrainy i problema globalizatsii grazhdanskogo protsessa]. Grazhdanskii protsess v mezhkul'turnom dialoge: evraziiskii kontekst: Vsemirnaia konferentsiia Mezhdunarodnoi assotsiatsii protsessual'nogo prava, 18-21 sentiabria 2012 g., Moskva, Rossiia: Sbornik dokladov (Civil process in intercultural dialogue: Eurasian Context: The World Conf. of the Inter. Association of Procedural Law, 18-21 September 2012, Moscow, Russia: Proceedings / Ed. by D.Ia. Maleshin). Moscow, 2012. P. 476-488. (in Russian).

3. Civil Procedure in Cross-cultural Dialogue: Eurasia Context: IAPL Word Conference on Civil Procedure, September 18-21, 2012, Moscow, Russia: Conference book / Ed. By Dmitry Maleshin; International Association of Procedural Law. Moscow: Statute, 2012. 608 p.

4. Alan Uzelach. Keynote report [Osnovnoi doklad]. Grazhdanskii protsess v mezhkul'turnom dialoge: evraziiskii kontekst: Vsemirnaia konferentsiia Mezhdunarodnoi assotsiatsii protsessual'nogo prava, 18-21 sentiabria 2012 g., Moskva, Rossiia: Sbornik dokladov (Civil process in intercultural dialogue: Eurasian Context: The World Conf. of the Inter. Association of Procedural Law, 18-21 September 2012, Moscow, Russia: Proceedings / Ed. by D.Ia. Maleshin). Moscow, 2012. Pp. 140-169. (in Russian).

5. Sukhova, N.V. The role of civil and arbitration proceedings in the modern legal reality. Vestnik Omskogo universiteta — Bulletin of Omsk University. 2009. № 4 (21). Series "Law".

P. 49-59. (in Russian).

6. Report on the criteria of the trial, prepared by the Quality Project in the courts under the urisdiction of the Court of Appeal of Rovaniemi / / Proekt sudov okruga Appeliatsionnogo suda Rovaniemi, Finliandiia. Otsenka kachestva razresheniia del v sudakh. Printsipy i predlagaemye kriterii kachestva. Mart, 2006 [Project vessels District Court of Appeal of Rovaniemi, Finland. Assessment of quality of solutions of cases in courts. Principles and criteria for the quality offered. March, 2006] / Transl. by A.G. Kotel'nikov, M.Iu. Kotel'nikova. Rovaniemi; Ekaterinburg — Oulu, 2007. 79 p. (in Russian).

7. Iarkov, V.V. Keynote report [Osnovnoi doklad]. Grazhdanskii protsess v mezhkul'turnom dialoge: evraziiskii kontekst: Vsemirnaia konferentsiia Mezhdunarodnoi assotsiatsii protsessual'nogo prava, 18-21 sentiabria 2012 g., Moskva, Rossiia: Sbornik dokladov (Civil process in intercultural dialogue: Eurasian Context: The World Conf. of the Inter. Association of Procedural Law, 18-21 September 2012, Moscow, Russia: Proceedings / Ed. by D.Ia. Maleshin). Moscow, 2012. Pp. 397-429. (in Russian).

8. Barak Aaron. Sudeiskoe usmotrenie [Judicial discretion] / Transl. fr. Eng. Moscow, 1999.

376 p. (in Russian).

9. Decision of the European Court of Human Rights in the case "Brumaresku against Romania" from October 28, 1999. Spravochnye pravovye sistemy — Legal reference system. (in Russian).

10. Decision of the European Court of Human Rights in the case "Gudkov against the Russian Federation" dated December 22, 2009. Biulleten' Evropeiskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka. Rossiiskoe izdanie — Bulletin of the European Court of Human Rights. Russian edition. 2010. № 6. Pp. 3, 35-37. (in Russian).

11. Storm, Marseille. Inducement report [Vvodnyi doklad]. Grazhdanskii protsess v mezhkul'turnom dialoge: evraziiskii kontekst: Vsemirnaia konferentsiia Mezhdunarodnoi assotsiatsii protsessual'nogo prava, 18-21 sentiabria 2012 g., Moskva, Rossiia: Sbornik dokladov (Civil process in intercultural dialogue: Eurasian Context: The World Conf. of the Inter. Association of Procedural Law, 18-21 September 2012, Moscow, Russia: Proceedings / Ed. by D.Ia. Maleshin). Moscow, 2012. P. 18-28. (in Russian).

12. Grazhdanskii protsess v mezhkul'turnom dialoge: evraziiskii kontekst: Vsemirnaia konferentsiia Mezhdunarodnoi assotsiatsii protsessual'nogo prava, 18-21 sentiabria 2012 g., Moskva, Rossiia: Sbornik dokladov [Civil process in intercultural dialogue: Eurasian Context: The World Conference of the International Association of Procedural Law, 18-21 September 2012, Moscow, Russia: Proceedings] / Ed. By D.Ia. Maleshin. Moscow, 2012. 720 p.

(in Russian).

13. Sukhova, N.V., Lits, M.O. The right to a fair trial: the problem of perception and application of the legal positions of the European Court of Human Rights in the Russian system of civil procedure [Pravo na spravedlivoe sudebnoe razbiratel'stvo: problemy vospriiatiia i primeneniia pravovykh pozitsii Evropeiskogo Suda po pravam cheloveka v rossiiskoi sisteme grazhdanskogo protsessa]. Rossiia i Evropa: sviaz' kul'tury i ekonomiki: Materialy VI mezhdunarodnoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii (21 iiunia 2013 g.) (Russia and Europe: the relationship of economics and culture: Proceedings of the VI International Scientific-Practical Conference (June 21, 2013)) / Ed. by Uvarina N.V. Prague, 2013. Pp. 39-46. (in Russian).

14. Terkhova, L.A. System review of judicial decisions in CPC RF. Vestnik grazhdanskogo protsessa — Bulletin of civil procedure. 2012. № 3. Pp. 29-52. (in Russian). 15. Gurvich, G.D. Filosofiia i sotsiologiia prava: Izbrannye sochineniia [Philosophy and Sociology of Law: Selected Writings] / Transl. by M.V. Antonova, L.V. Voronova. St-Petersburg, 2004. 848 p.

(in Russian).

16. Alekseev, N.N. Osnovy filosofii prava [Fundamentals of Philosophy of Law]. St-Petersburg, 1999. 256 p. (in Russian).

17. Kurochkin, S.A. Chastnye i publichnye nachala v tsivilisticheskom protsesse [Private and public basic principles in the civil process] / Ed. by V.V. Iarkov. Moscow, 2012. 560 p.

(in Russian).

18. Kistiakovskii, B.A. Filosofiia i sotsiologiia prava [Philosophy and Sociology of Law] Comp., N., Op. V.V. Sapova. St-Petersburg, 1999. 800 p. (in Russian).

19. Maleshin, D.Ia. Metodologiia grazhdanskogo protsessual'nogo prava [Methodology of civil procedural law]. Moscow, 2010. 208 p. (in Russian).

20. Cukhova, N.V. In defense of the court [V zashchitu suda]. APK i GPK 2002 g.: sravnitel'nyi analiz i aktual'nye problemy pravoprimeneniia. M-ly Vseross. nauch.- praktich. konf. (AIC and GIC in 2002: a comparative analysis of current and enforcement problems: All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conf.). Moscow, 2004. P. 45-49. (in Russian).

21. Petrazhitskii, L.I. Introduction to the study of law and morality. Basics emotional psychology. (St-Petersburg, 1908) / / Teoriia i politika prava. Izbrannye trudy [Theory and policy of the law. Selected Works] / Scientific ed. E.V. Timoshina. St-Petersburg, 2010. 1104 p. (in Russian).

22. Poliakov, A.V. Obshchaia teoriia prava: problemy interpretatsii v kontekste kommunikativnogo podkhoda: Kurs lektsii [General theory of law: problems of interpretation in the context of the communicative approach: Lectures]. St-Petersburg, 2004. 864 p. (in Russian).